Sale! indianapolis famous condiment 4-pack
Indianapolis Famous 4-Pack Descriptionindianapolis product shot 1indianapolis product shot 2

The Indianapolis Famous Condiment 4-Pack

$59.99 $54.99

With a local design, beautiful presentation and premium condiments made famous in the city, this package is an excellent gift for showing off the famous flavors of Indianapolis.

This Indianapolis Famous Condiment 4-Pack includes the following:

– St. Elmo’s Shrimp Cocktail Sauce (12 oz)
– Squealers Smokin’ Hot Barbecue Sauce (18 oz)
– BestBoy Bourbon Barrel Caramel Sauce (10 oz)
– LocalFolks Stoneground Xxpress Mustard (8 oz)

Comes with FREE:

  • shipping
  • personalized note
  • guaranteed delivery date

These condiments all have special meanings to the city of Indianapolis, and you’ll get their unique stories along with the condiments themselves when you buy the box.

Ordering 10 or more? Check out our gifting deals!

Category: Tag:

Product Description

What’s inside:

St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce


St. Elmo’s Shrimp Cocktail Sauce – 12 oz.

Named the “world’s spiciest food” by critic Allison Stein Werner in 2008 and featured on the Food Network’s “The Best Thing I Ever Ate” in 2010, St. Elmo’s Shrimp Cocktail Sauce is hard to forget thanks to its powerful horseradish punch. Made with all natural ingredients and no preservatives, this condiment is a quintessential piece of the culinary history of Indianapolis.

Squealers Smokin' Hot Sauce


Squealers’ Smokin’ Hot BBQ Sauce – 18 oz.

The famous Squealers Smokin’ Hot Sauce has won 11 national and regional awards in barbeque competitions. Not nearly as intimidating as it sounds, this sauce has a gentle-but-sufficient jalapeno kick delivered through a bold tomato-base that is truly unique to Squealers and Indianapolis.

Best Boy Bourbon Barrel Caramel Sauce


Best Boy Bourbon Barrel Caramel Sauce – 10 oz.

The Bourbon Barrel Caramel Sauce is one of Best Boy’s best-selling dessert condiments. Made with locally-famous Bad Elmer’s Porter from Bloomington’s own Upland Brewery, it has a full-bodied flavor and a creamy consistency, making it a perfect complement to apples, pretzels, ice cream or just about any other dessert you can imagine.

LocalFolks Stoneground Xxpress Mustard


 LocalFolks’ Stoneground Xxpress Mustard – 8 oz.

The Stoneground Xxpress Mustard is LocalFolks Foods’ best-selling product. This fresh, stone-ground mustard is lightly sweetened with a little honey and ripe red bell peppers, making it a perfect complement to any sandwich.

Additional Information

Attribute Information
Weight 100 oz
Dimensions 14 x 9 x 4 in

11 reviews for The Indianapolis Famous Condiment 4-Pack

  1. Chandler Chapman
    5 out of 5

    I don’t always know what to get my dad for Christmas (I thought, another tie?). But I saw this and knew it was the perfect gift! So excited to give it to him 🙂

    View Comment
  2. Will Tilbury
    5 out of 5

    Fantastic gift, my father loved it. Arrived two days after I placed the order, and the quality of the box and the products within was exceptional. Will be ordering again for future gifts for friends and family!

    View Comment
  3. Brad
    5 out of 5

    My girlfriend and I bought the Indy boxes as a Christmas gift to her dad and mine. This is a perfect gift idea for your dad (or even mom) if you have no idea what to get them. My favorite part is the one-pager within the box that provides in-depth detail on each condiment included. It’s so cool to read about the history and story of each one. The customer service was great and we can’t wait to show up to Christmas this year with the coolest gifts out of everyone in our families. Thanks again, Eric!

    View Comment
  4. Lizzy Colle
    5 out of 5

    Wow, where do I begin? What a fun, unique gift idea for foodies that love to eat local. I have tried to put together my own local food gift boxes before, but they always take up way more time and effort than intended. Luckily, Condiment Connection has found a solution and come up with a fantastic product! Great customer service, easy local pick-up, and my Indy box even came up with a personalized note from the seller. Cannot wait to give this gift over the holidays, and order more in the future!

    View Comment
  5. Joe C.
    5 out of 5

    A very unique gift that can be great for those who are missing their hometown flavor or for exploring the taste of cities which they’ve never been to!

    Since I live/work in Chicago, I ordered the Chicago gift box for my department’s gift exchange and plenty of people were intrigued by it. Even if someone hadn’t heard of one of the condiments, the write-up describing the roots of the product and the restaurant itself is a great way to familiarize with the condiment and restaurant itself. I also ordered an Indy gift package for my parents, who were delighted to find St. Elmo’s shrimp cocktail sauce included!

    In addition, Eric made sure they were delivered to my apartment less than 3 business days after placing the order.

    Can’t wait to see what’s included in the next city’s 4-pack!

    View Comment
  6. Sam Fazzini
    5 out of 5

    My roommates and I thought it would be fun to do a Secret Santa exchange, with a price range about $40. Girls can be so picky, but everyone love condiments, so this was literally a perfect gift!!!!! I def wanted to get the Indy pack, my roommates, both being from St. Louis, would love it.

    Obvi, I left buying a gift to the last minute, Eric was able to ship to Chicago within 1 day. Talk about great service!!

    Remember boys, girls love condiments too 😉

    View Comment
  7. keryn
    5 out of 5

    Bought both the Chicago and the Indianapolis pack and am absolutely thrilled! Customer service kept me informed of the package’s status and presentation can’t be beat. Love the fact that you give the info about each condiment. It is a delicious and fun gift! I can hardly wait for CC to expand into other areas. Something for everyone!

    View Comment
  8. Kevin
    5 out of 5

    The Indy Famous 4-Pack is fantastic. Can’t stop eating that St. Elmo’s cocktail sauce, even though it burns. The others are amazing as well. Shipped the day I ordered it and was here probably 48 hours later. Excellent service.

    View Comment
  9. Roslyn Spelman
    5 out of 5

    This is a great Gift! The products were of great quality as well. Pleased with the entire experience . Eric was great
    I would highly recommend
    Roslyn Spelman

    View Comment

Add a Review